Divinity Anthology

[WaltonSimons]

Finally got around to doing this on my machine.

Here's a more detailed critique/feedback. Hope it's useful for the future. Take note that it's just subjective opinion and nobody should feel OBLIGATED to agree with it. It's an opinion, not scientific fact.

The bad:

- buttons on start screen: red text on red buttons? (white only on highlight?) unreadable
- start screen: the red bars between images look completely unlike you. You can do much better, Mouse. Much better.
- lack of II in Divinity Original Sin II logo on start screen.
- Divinity Anthology has its own logo. - granted it's from a smaller set but what was stopping you from adding a 2016 on top of it?
- same issue with the splash screen ("Divine" Divinity Anthology? :-P) and the main setup window.
- alphabetic ordering of the components also looks weird given that this series of games has a sequence (LMK, Divine, Beyond, II, Commander, OS1, OS2) and I believe an anthology type conversion SHOULD reflect that.

The good:

- the music choices and the screenshot choices.
- well, it works as a repackaging of the games, I'll give you this much.

Overall, with your previous fullfillments of my requests, you really came through. The installers were ultimate in eye candy and there were next to no issues with them - and if there were, they were being fixed fast.

However this looks more like you were in a hurry to get this off your chest. I'm sorry if it was the case because if I made you feel this way, the fault is all mine. However, this does look genuinely rushed. 6/10 from me.

[mausschieber]

Originally Posted by WaltonSimons

Finally got around to doing this on my machine.

Here's a more detailed critique/feedback. Hope it's useful for the future. Take note that it's just subjective opinion and nobody should feel OBLIGATED to agree with it. It's an opinion, not scientific fact.

The bad:

- buttons on start screen: red text on red buttons? (white only on highlight?) unreadable
- start screen: the red bars between images look completely unlike you. You can do much better, Mouse. Much better.
- lack of II in Divinity Original Sin II logo on start screen.
- Divinity Anthology has its own logo. - granted it's from a smaller set but what was stopping you from adding a 2016 on top of it?
- same issue with the splash screen ("Divine" Divinity Anthology? :-P) and the main setup window.
- alphabetic ordering of the components also looks weird given that this series of games has a sequence (LMK, Divine, Beyond, II, Commander, OS1, OS2) and I believe an anthology type conversion SHOULD reflect that.

The good:

- the music choices and the screenshot choices.
- well, it works as a repackaging of the games, I'll give you this much.

Overall, with your previous fullfillments of my requests, you really came through. The installers were ultimate in eye candy and there were next to no issues with them - and if there were, they were being fixed fast.

However this looks more like you were in a hurry to get this off your chest. I'm sorry if it was the case because if I made you feel this way, the fault is all mine. However, this does look genuinely rushed. 6/10 from me.

Thanks for your opinion, I will implement your suggestions and make it the next time better