Anyone successfully backup Chamber of Secrets?

[Preyhunter]

Damnit, I'm THIS close to giving up on this. I've tried using 74 and 80 min cds, I've used clonecd with the profile that PSX_Paul provided, I've tried with both recorders (which should support reading of subchannel data), I've tried different speeds and different brands of media. All attempts have gotten me the same thing...one wizard card on the loading screen.

If anyone has ANY more ideas (other than "get a no-swap chip"), let me know. I don't think the no-solder/swap magic combo is the problem because I get beyond the point that those are supposed to get me to. Maybe it's just my machine? Anyone want to trade backup copies to see if mine works on your machine and yours works on mine? Will that get me in trouble here? Help!