The CDD 4851 is not fully compatible with CloneCD and so sub-channel data is not handled correctly. You need at least DAO-RAW+96 (not RAW+16).
CDRWin - well CDD4851 is not listed in the compatibility chart.
If you'd followed the tuts at
www.psxcopyworld.co.uk AND the reader/burner was compatible, it would have worked.
Yamaha 2200 would do the job.