Alright, after hours of searching, I finally got a copy of CD-Copy 2.0 that works.
But here's my new problem... When I copy the tracks and save, then open them in Toast, the program claims it's too much data for 1 CD.
I'm trying to backup disc 1 of Syphon Filter 2, which is a single track... So there's no way I can see to trim it.
Help?