Finally copied YuGiOh perfectly, and works with modded psx- here's how
 

Just in case some of you haven't figured it out, here's what i did.

Download the newest cdrwin
DO NOT USE KEYGENS/PATCHES to register it, it might not work
Copy the game following the instructions found on this site
Patch the game using the instructions on this site
Burn it with all the default settings, but turn on RAW MODE.

I have a LiteOn 40x burner and i run Xp, if it matters. Hopefully raw mode is not required, as i'm not sure if all burners support it. But if you have it, it should work.